Del.icio.us
Yesterday, Mark cited a UNICEF report on the abhorrent crimes committed against children in Port-au-Prince, Haiti. Via FP Passport, though, I came across this somewhat surprising article in the Christian Science Monitor, describing that, even according to the UN force operating in Haiti, the situation is not quite as bad as it seems:
Kidnappings, gang violence, drug trafficking, corrupt police, flaming road blockades.The reports out of the poorest country in the Western Hemisphere are enough to keep the most adventurous traveler away.
But according to security experts and officials from the United Nations peacekeeping mission in Port-au-Prince, Haiti is no more violent than any other country in Latin America.
"It's a big myth," says Fred Blaise, spokesman for the UN police force in Haiti. "Port-au-Prince is no more dangerous than any big city. You can go to New York and get pickpocketed and held at gunpoint. The same goes for cities in Mexico or Brazil."
Haiti's negative image has devastated its economy, whose once-booming tourism industry is now limited largely to aid workers, peacekeepers, and diplomats.
But UN data indicate that the country could be among the safest in the region.
While such data does not diminish the reprehensible nature of any number of kidnappings and rapes -- nor is it entirely reassuring to think that one may "only" be "pickpocketed and and held at gunpoint" -- there does seem to be some degree of sensationalism in reporting rampant violence in Haiti. The situation there is still intolerable, with hundreds of thousands suffering from hunger and extreme poverty, but perhaps a little tourism would help Haitians more than it might put travelers at risk.
Comments
Forgiving Haiti's debt would help Haitians too. I'm for doing that.
Posted by: eRobin at June 24, 2008 9:21 PM
During the so-called bloody, brutal Duvalier dictatorship I could travel anywhere in Haiti, day or night, alone in complete safety. No one would bother you. Up until the Aristide period, no foreigner was ever harmed.
Law-and-order was maintained by the Forces Armees d�Haiti and Police with a total of something like 7000 poorly equipped men. Now the UN says Haiti needs 35,000 police to control the country.
Obviously there is something wrong with the earlier perception of the Duvalier presidency or the reporting and perceptions under the Aristide/Preval governments
Now Haiti experiences and ongoing instability generated by Aristide, from South Africa, and the Haitian government, from Preval�s residence. There might be some copycat crimes but the basis for the chaos comes from these two partners in crime. They are still connected and communicate with regularity.
Today, in June of 2008 there is no confidence in the security. Kidnapping ebbs and rises at the whim of governmental requirements. Dozens of men women and children, Haitian and foreign have been grabbed in all areas of the nation. Many prominent people have been kidnapped and ransomed with no publicity. Kidnapping is a growth industry.
I cannot even walk a hundred yards to a major gas station in Petionville to buy a phone card. My associates are afraid that I might be grabbed. Only last week a man was kidnapped in from of St Therese, a major Catholic church one block away. Two nights ago, a woman was taken 20 feet from my gate.
Children are kidnapped and raped while the criminal demand ransom. Sometimes the children are mutilated and killed after the ransom has been paid.
Haiti has become truly Democratic with the United Nations assistance. Now no one is safe from the criminals, Americans, Canadians, Europeans, South Americans and Haitians of all social and economic standings. Democracy has been a gift from Aristide/Preval and their friends.
Jean Claude Duvalier, where are you. We could welcome a return to your blood, murderous dictatorship where all Haitians and foreigners could travel the nations byways in complete and total safety.
The garbage that the UN pedals, suggesting that Haiti is no more dangerous that other places is insulting in the extreme. They have taken a peaceful nation � with little or no violence � and elevated it to the point where UIN experts compare it to New York, Las Angeles and Chicago.
It is disgusting, but the UN is an empire-building organization and wants to maintain control of Haiti. Haiti is worth billions of dollars to it each year of the UN occupation. Lots of big jobs, with enormous salaries and fringe benefits, for guys and girls who could not find similar jobs in the real world.
Posted by: Jean Cadorel at June 25, 2008 9:41 AM
Whenever you here a comparison likening a city's crime rate to NYC, you know you are dealing with an ignorant statement based on outdated stereotypes and not on accuate statistics. NYC has been for a number of years one of the safest large cities in the world, Port-au-Prince a place with a terrifying kidnap rate. The UN needs a new spokesman for Haiti.
Posted by: Sam at June 25, 2008 1:52 PM

RSS


