Can we talk about human rights yet?
Email | Digg! Digg | Del.icio.us

Discussing Myanmar's invitation for the UN envoy to the country, Ibrahim Gambari, to visit the country, Louis Charbonneau of Reuters writes:

Security Council diplomats in New York say that enough time has past since Cyclone Nargis hit Myanmar two months ago, leaving 138,000 dead or missing, and that it is time to ratchet up the pressure on the junta to comply with council demands that it improve the state of human rights and democracy.

It's hard to say whether this is due to Charbonneau's peculiar way of phrasing this sentence, or whether Security Council diplomats are actually thinking along these lines on the matter, but there is something objectionable in the notion that the UN needs to wait "enough time" after a major humanitarian disaster to continue promoting human rights and democracy in a member country. Myanmar's obstruction of relief efforts did indeed make delivery of humanitarian aid an immediate priority, but this should not be seen as in exclusion of human rights concerns. Rather, the two are tied up quite intimately.

At any rate, it's far from certain whether Myanmar's most recent invitation will result in open access for Gambari, or whether the country's leaders will repeat past practice.

Gambari has said his most recent visit to Myanmar was a disappointment and yielded no concrete results. One of the problems was that he was unable to meet senior junta leaders.

Comments

The invitation to the UN
special envoy to visit
Myanmar since his failed
March visit reflects a
planned mission to legiti
mate its discipline flour
ising democracy and the
programme for a multiparty
institution in 2010. The
junta's move is influenced by
by the situation in Sudan
where Pres. Basher is
charged of genocide and
will soon received his
arrest warrant. The inclin
ing use of UN tool to pres
sure the junta to openness
by France, US and British
is upsurging.

Posted by: soharto ali at July 16, 2008 6:18 AM

Post a comment




Remember Me?

(you may use HTML tags for style)

September 25, 2008


Halfway to the Millennium Development Goals
Email | Digg! Digg | Del.icio.us

The following appeared as an op-ed in The Guardian Online on Thursday, September 25th.

This week, over 150 world leaders are gathered at the UN for the opening of the general assembly. If recent years are any indication, news outlets will focus on the disagreements aired on Tuesday, when George Bush and Mahmoud Ahmadinejad took the podium.

But the real drama occurs today (Thursday), when the same global leaders that butted heads earlier in the week take stock of one of the most far-reaching and noble statements of international cooperation ever agreed upon, the millennium development goals.

More.

Dispatch Tweets
UN Dispatch's full feed
Related Posts