Site Meter UN Dispatch | Page 1065 of 1319 | United Nations News & Commentary Global News - ForumUN Dispatch | United Nations News & Commentary Global News – Forum | Page 1065
Increase Font Size Decrease Font Size

All Posts

Why it’s better to be Idriss Deby than a Darfurian civilian

On Monday, the Security Council issued a statement condemning the rebel assault on Chad’s capital, N’Djamena and urging Member States to support the Chadian government. The speed at which the Security Council responded to this threat underscores the distinction between defending a sovereign government from rebel attack and responding to a genocide perpetrated by a government on its own people.

Even though the Security Council’s statement had been toned down to omit references to military force or to Sudanese involvement in the attack, it implicitly gave France, which maintains 1,400 troops in Chad, the green light to defend President Idriss Deby’s government. French president Nicolas Sarkozy explicitly articulated his country’s willingness to intervene militarily, asserting yesterday that “if France must do its duty, it will do so.” In the tragic history of the Darfur genocide, by contrast, no country has so baldly proclaimed its readiness to pony up military support — or even peacekeepers or equipment — in the face of opposition from the Sudanese government.This dynamic — whereby it is easier to protect a head of state than millions of civilian victims — is in a sense a natural byproduct of the state sovereignty system under which the UN operates. Thus, a UN-authorized coalition invaded Iraq to defend the sovereign state of Kuwait from Saddam Hussein’s invasion in 1991, but the international community had only dithered when the despot gassed Kurds in his own country three years earlier. And while President Deby can feel secure after the rebels’ retreat and the prospect of French support, Darfurians still await the batch of helicopters for the much-delayed peacekeeping force that has been slowly and falteringly cobbled together to protect them.

It is unreasonable to expect that countries would leap at the opportunity to send military forces into a sovereign territory that overtly objects to their presence. To achieve the ultimate goal of balancing these two imperatives — respecting sovereign governments and protecting their populations — countries must embrace the emerging “Responsibility to Protect” (or R2P) doctrine, which creates powerful incentives for states to protect their own people and outlines a contingency scheme in the case of state failure. The UN has theoretically adopted this bold new framework for international relations, but its support thus far has been merely hortatory. Member States must step up and demonstrate their commitment to R2P, so that innocent civilians do not continue to languish unprotected, while beleaguered governments reap the benefits of their sovereign status.

| 1 Comment

Opium and the Insurgency

The United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime released a new report warning of another huge opium harvest in Afghanistan this year. This from the New York Times

Afghanistan will produce another enormous opium poppy crop this year, close to last year’s record harvest, and Europe and other regions should brace themselves for the expected influx of heroin, the United Nations warned in its annual winter survey of poppy planting patterns.

Cultivation is still increasing in the insurgency-hit south and west of the country, the report said, and taxes on the crop have become a major source of revenue for the Taliban insurgency.

“This is a windfall for antigovernment forces, further evidence of the dangerous link between opium and insurgency,” Antonio Maria Costa, the executive director of the United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime, wrote in the report’s preface.

Full report here.

| Leave a comment

Wednesday Morning Coffee

Obama won more states, but Clinton claimed more delegates, and the battle continues. McCain solidified his frontrunner status in the Republican primary (even though Huckabee wasn’t too shabby).

Top Stories


>>Chad – Rebel attacks have ceased in Ndjamena in the wake of France’s declaration that it would get involved if necessary and the dispatch of troops by a Darfur rebel group in order to bolster Chad’s president. France’s Defense Minister, Herve Morin, is in town.

>>Afghanistan – The UN Office on Drugs and Crime has reported that opium cultivation increased by 14 percent in 2007 in southern and southwestern Afghanistan, bolstering the insurgency with up to $100 million. Marijuana production is also on the rise. Outside of rebel strongholds, production decreased.

>>Pakistan – Taliban fighters in Pakistan have declared a ceasefire after months of fighting that has left hundreds dead.

>>Counting the Dead – The BBC reports on the work of the International Rescue Committee, who has taken on the responsibility of counting the dead in difficult to reach places. By their estimates, 45,000 people a month are dying in the Democratic Republic of the Congo.

Quotes of the Day
  • “Indeed, it is the insurgents, the Taliban, that are deriving an enormous funding for their war by imposing … a 10 percent tax on production”
    - Antonio Maria Costa,
    executive director of the UN Office on Drugs and Crime
  • “People aren’t dying dramatically. They’re dying quietly and anonymously … In the eyes of Western powers, Congo doesn’t represent major political or economic interest.”
    – Richard Brennan of aid agency International Rescue Committee
Yesterday in UN Dispatch

The Rest of the Story
  • Russia
    regrets vote watchdog rebuffed offer: report
  • href="">Chechen
    Warns of Islamic Extremism
  • href="">Arms
    obscure view of the world
  • href="">Roman
    Nikolaichik, critic of Vladimir Putin, is sent to mental hospital
  • href="">Iran
    bars grandson of the revolution leader from election run
  • href="">Sri
    Lanka jets bomb rebels, no end to war in sight
  • href="">European
    watchdog rejects Russian election offer
  • href="">Dangerous
    to use Mexico army against drug gangs: UN
  • href="">South
    Africa has doubts about new Iran sanctions
  • href="">France
    unveils TGV’s successor
  • href="">G7
    likely to reject idea of concerted stimulus
  • href="">Kiev’s
    WTO step to loosen Russia grip
  • href="">Intelligence
    official revives Iran doubts
  • href="">Dumplings
    poisoned ‘on purpose’
  • href="">Nuclear
    smuggler sentence in SA
  • href="">Italy
    leader ‘to call snap polls’
  • href="">US
    slaps new sanctions on Burma
  • href="">CIA
    chief admits waterboarding
  • href="">Holidays
    begin in snow-hit China
  • href="">BJP
    meetings hit by attack fears
  • href="">Work
    begins to repair severed net
  • href="">Turkish
    MPs voting on headscarfs
  • href="">Kenya
    Death Toll Surpasses 1,000
  • href="">Hamas
    Claims Responsibility for Blast
  • href="">Italian
    parliament is dissolved
  • href="">Kenyan
    opposition makes new protest threat
Leave a comment

President Bush’s budget beefs up defense spending, shortchanges UN peacekeeping

In the record-setting $3.1 trillion budget proposal that he unveiled yesterday, President Bush allocated nearly $1.5 billion for 18 UN peacekeeping missions across the world. While the administration lauds the budget’s contributions to helping “end conflicts, restore peace, and strengthen regional stability,” this figure actually falls over half a billion dollars short of the amount that the US needs to provide for these UN missions to perform effectively. Moreover, the $610 million shortfall that this gap creates will only add to the $1.195 billion that the US still owes in arrears to UN peacekeeping.The insufficient US funding for UN peacekeeping missions is even more striking when compared to the enormity of the FY2009 budget for the Department of Defense. DoD’s base budget of $515 billion already represents the highest inflation-adjusted level of military spending since World War II, and, much to Democrats’ consternation, emergency allowances for the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan push the budget to over $600 billion. This number dwarfs the State Department budget of $39 billion and strongly suggests a heightened focus on military defense over diplomacy and peacekeeping.

The administration nonetheless recognizes the high value of diplomacy, trumpeting the increase in funds “to support key allies in the Global War on Terror and improve responses to international crises.” However, the money allocated to support the militaries of countries like Egypt ($1.3 billion) and Israel ($2.55 billion) stands in sharp relief to the funds left out of UN peacekeeping budget. The best way for the US to contribute to international peace and stability is to follow through on its treaty obligations and its votes in the Security Council by fully funding UN peacekeeping missions.

| Leave a comment

How a Peacekeeping Mission Fails…And Can be Rescued

Not Darfur, but the mission along the Ethiopian-Eritrean border, UNMEE. The Secretary General today warned that unless the Eritrean government lifts restrictions the import and purchase of fuel, the UN Peacekeeping mission along the Eritrea-Ethiopia border will have to fold. The mission has just two days left until it must tap into strategic fuel reserves.

UNMEE was created in 2000 to monitor a ceasefire along a disputed border region between. Both countries, though, have not made life easy for the peacekeeping force — at various times, the two governments have hindered UNMEE’s operations by throwing up bureaucratic roadblocks. Manufacturing a fuel shortage is simply the latest manifestation of the governments’ strategies to undermine the mission.

As always in these situations what’s needed is pressure from member states. If members of the Security Council think that UNMEE is worthwhile, (and they should, given the fact that the Council just extended the mission for another six months) they must do more to twist the arms of the Ethiopian and Eritrean Government to secure their cooperation.

| Leave a comment

Super Tuesday Morning Coffee

America votes and spends.

Top Stories

>>Zimbabwe – Robert Mugabe’s reign as president will be challenged for the first time in 20 years by Simba Makoni, a “reform-minded technocrat” and a senior member of the ruling ZANU-PF party. Opposition parties have proven unable to reunify under a consensus candidate, presumably now splitting the anti-ruling party vote.

>>Italy – An attempt to avoid snap election in Italy seems to have failed, as Senate president Franco Marini has failed to build a workable interim governing coalition. Former PM Silvio Berlusconi appears to be the frontrunner. President Giorgio Napolitano, and others, worry that, if the nation’s unique electoral laws are not reformed before the next government is elected, it will be as unstable as the former. Italy has had more than 60 governments since WWII.

>>Chad – Chadian rebels continue to attack Ndjamena, as France has threatened intervention if the seige continues. The 1,400-strong French force has already defended the airport form attack. In an emergency session, the UN Security Council condemned the rebel attacks and authorized member states to provide support for the Chadian government. UN relief workers are attempting to reopen a camp to administer food and shelter to those who have fled to Cameroon; two airlift flights are planned for this week.

>>East Timor – The United Nations has begun transferring power back to East Timor’s police force. In 2006, the UN stepped in to end warring between the nation’s police force and miltary, sparked when a third of the army was dismissed for desertion.

Yesterday in UN Dispatch

Leave a comment

Diplo Tweets