Site Meter Sri Lanka Wants to Export War Crimes | UN Dispatch
Increase Font Size Decrease Font Size

Sri Lanka Wants to Export War Crimes

From the AFP:

Sri Lanka’s army Wednesday announced plans to share with other countries its success in crushing ethnic Tamil Tiger rebels and ending the island’s 37-year-old separatist war.

Army chief Lieutenant General Jagath Jayasuriya said they were inviting heads of military and defence establishments in 54 countries to a three-day forum starting in Colombo from May 31.

“After the war ended many countries have requested us to share some of our strategies with them,” Jayasuriya told reporters in Colombo. “They want us to share our experience and expertise with them.”

For the record, the Sri Lankan military did launch a remarkably successful counter-insurgency which appears to have crushed, once and for all, the brutal Tamil Tigers.  The thing is, the strategy was predicated upon committing massive war crimes. E.g:

Starting in late January, the government and security forces encouraged hundreds of thousands of civilians to move into ever smaller government-declared No Fire Zones (NFZs) and then subjected them to repeated and increasingly intense artillery and mortar barrages and other fire. This continued through May despite the government and security forces knowing the size and location of the civilian population and scale of civilian casualties.

There are two potential lessons that governments which struggle with insurgency can take from the Sri Lanka example.  The first is that the ends justify the means; slaughtering 10,000 non-combatants is worth it if you can crush a rebellion.  Given the fact that the Sri Lankan military is celebrating the manner in which it defeated the Tamil Tigers that is presumably the lesson that they have drawn.

On the other hand, if there was some sort of credible criminal investigation into these war crimes–and if that investigation ended up with the arrest and trial of the accused–other regimes might think twice before they use the counter-insurgency-by-mass atrocity tactic.

So far, though, there is no credible international or local judicial process to look into allegations of crimes against humanity. One credible mechanism would be the International Criminal Court. But since Sri Lanka is not a member, it would take an act of the Security Council to grant the ICC the jurisdiction to investigate.  That does not seem likely any time soon.

For now impunity is ruling the day.  So much so, that Sri Lanka is apparently seeking to export its brand of counter-insurgency to other countries.

This is the biggest challenge to international justice in the world today. Will the Sri Lankan method of dealing with rebellion and insurgency catch on elsewhere? Or will the long arm of international justice give pause to would-be war criminals?

This is pretty much the defining question of international justice these days. So far, the good guys seem to be losing.


  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_LK6QJPFB3TEXR57JTC4XIA5IBA Doosra Fernando

    Absolute rubbish, Mr. Goldberg. You have to be incredibly naive to think a terrorist movement more dangerous than Al-Qaeda could be defeated by claims of indiscriminate shelling. Please do your research. The Sri Lankan Army opening its doors to share information is a positive sign. Furthermore, ending wars always saves lives – its something Israelis have trouble grasping, and something Sri Lanka has achieved. Allegations of war crimes are exactly what they are, taking a the ICG’s comment out of context can only fool the ignorant.

  • samarasinghe

    Mr Goldberg you are completely mad. the tamil tiger terrorists despite many pleadings by the srilankan govt and the UN to let the civilians go for months did not let civilians go and kept them as a human shield. the srilanka govt almost begged the tamil tigers to surrender and end the war which they didnt do either.

    the srilankan army went to great lengths to precisely to make sure there were hardly any civilians casualties and to make sure civilains suffering was kept to a minimum.

    please stop being the unofficial spokesperson for the tiger terrorist group. it is shameful to be so obvious.

  • http://twitter.com/torontotamil M. Arunan

    Yes, the LTTE used terrorist tactics, but the anti Tamil campaign by Sri Lanka state has been going under various fig leaf for more than 6 decades now. Disenfranchisement, pogroms to uprooting Tamils in large scale from their habitats still continues. The Tamils do have a moral highground but it was eroded or eclipsed by LTTE ‘insurgency’…

    These are glimpse of what is happening today under the iron clad control of Sri Lanka, with military officials taking over civil functions in Tamil villages and towns to diplomats with alleged crimes are walking the corridors of diplmacy..this is what Sri Lanka wants to export..Thank you Leon Goldberg.

    Bishop Thomas Savundaranayagam of Jaffna has appealed to top military in Sri Lanka’s restive north to bring an end to what he described as a wave of terror.

    http://www.ucanews.com/2011/01/25/government-forces-failing-to-curb-violence/

    Vanni, northern Sri Lanka, where war has never ended

    http://www.asianews.it/news-en/Vanni,-northern-Sri-Lanka,-where-war-has-never-ended-18558.html

  • Toddluca

    What about the war crimes committed by Blair and Bush, Mr. Goldberg ? Didn’t Blair even recently apologize for the “iraq war dead” ?
    Oh yeah, War Crimes charges or even the thought of it doesn’t come to your mind when it’s committed by the rich and the powerful eh ?

    • Richard

      Why not let an independent inquiry like the one held for Blair eh???Why run away???

  • http://twitter.com/sandeepgu Sandeepan G’singham

    54 nations have already signed up for the three-day forum beginning from May 31. This author thinks that a few artillery shells and baseless allegations of war crimes defeated a group that had a navy, air wing, and a budget bigger than the British conservative party’s. Sri Lanka overwhelmed the Tamil Tigers who were at one time controlling one third of the island’s land mass and two-third’s of the coast and regarded one of the world’s most ruthlessly efficient guerrilla outfits in the world. They pioneered the suicide bomb/vest that Islamic extremist are using to kill your own today. Sri Lanka is not a small island it is larger than the state of Florida. So this was a big deal.

    • Johnny

      Thank you Mr. G’singham for highlighting this issue. These “journalists” make a living by writing about whatever shortcomings that exists in small, poor countries. Thats how they get their “pulitzer prizes”, etc. They wouldn’t dare to write about or try to investigate the crimes committed by powerful nations. This is why these same guys try to distance themselves from Julian Assange by saying that he is not a journalist because thats how they operate….just by attacking poor countries and staying away from doing the same to the big players.

  • Bhavanidash

    Absolutely, right. Good article. Sri Lanka is the worst human rights abuser and committed warcrimes and crimes against humanity. 146,000 Tamils are missing from the area of Vannia after the war. ~According to Government agent’s records,there were some 500,000 people lived in the area of Vanni, after the war only 300,000 odd people counted. Where are the rest gone? UN officially said some 7000 people killed. The Times and many other’s reported more than 20,000 were killed in the last days of the war! Sri Lankan militay told the people go to the ‘no fire zone’ then bombed the area. This is what Sri Lanka want to promote all around the world!

  • Dharmalover

    Thanks for highlighting this issue. There are two additional points to raise. First, governments of the west, whose troops and military leaders themselves are not free of credible allegations of war crimes, and of emerging democracies in the global south, have an important choice to make, which their citizens/tax-payers need to be aware of: should they send their military attaches and other officials to attend the Colombo conference, knowing that it is part of the Sri Lankan government’s international campaign to cleanse their reputation and legitimate their willful and extensive violation of the most basic laws of war? The answer is no, but it’s up to US and British and European and Indian and South African citizens to to make this clear to their governments and to prevent them from sanctioning the SL military’s illegality. Second, there is another route to the kind of credible, independent, international investigation into war crimes allegations, other than through the ICC or the Security Council. The Secretary General himself can appoint a commission of inquiry. He is currently awaiting the report from his three member panel of experts to advise him on accountability issues in Sri Lanka. We can hope that the panel will recommend that he launch an investigation of his own, and should this happen we can all urge the Secretary General to act on this advice. We can also all urge our respective governments to support the SG in this decision.

  • Hickson

    When war crimes are committed by powerful nations, it’s called “Iraqi Freedom” by these so-called “journalists” like Mr. Goldman.

  • Richard

    Many Srilankans have expressed support for their goverment below..This shows they too have supported these crimes.Srilankan goverment commited crimes against Tamils ever since 1948 and still continues depsite war being over.!Srilankans if they think they are innocent over war crimes why not investigate,like the one being held for Blair.!Mr.Goldman ignore these comments below.You have done the right job.You can ask any tamil for that matter.!

  • Anonymous

    Thank you Mr. Goldberg for bringing some sanity to the 21st century! I wonder sometimes if the world is civilized! At least there are saner voices like yours.

    Please visit the following web-site for a look at some of the executions of blindfolded, bound and naked innocent Tamils by Sri Lankan forces: One of the victims include a famous TV host, singer and artist:
    http://www.lobbyforpeace.com

    Please boycott Sri Lanka and its products (mostly apparel and tea) to bring Sri Lankan government to its knees:
    http://www.boycottsrilanka.com

  • Pmundra

    The Sri Lankan counterinsurgency operation saved lives. The Tamil Tigers were a ruthless bunch that would have prolonged the civil war for a few more decades if they were able to or if Mr. Goldberg’s mentality was followed by the government.

    War is a brutal, violent and murderous business. People get killed. Westerners like Goldberg are not so concerned with the final death count over the course of a conflict, but the rate at which the killing occurs. 10,000 souls lost in an intense, no-holds barred war lasting a year creates more wailing, gnashing of teeth and war crimes canards than 100,000 dead in a half-assed counterinsurgency lasting a quarter century.

    The Sri Lankan Army fought superlatively. After years of mollycoddling Western sensibilities they decided to fight to WIN and win QUICKLY. They realized that war conducted to suit the left-wing indignation attention span is a sure recipe for disaster, defeat and more death.

Diplo Tweets